Because FLOSS is handy, isn’t it?

Journalists + strict logic = ?

Posted by isilanes on June 27, 2006

This morning I had breakfast watching some journalists on TV, discussing the morning news in a kind of informal debate. They were speaking about judge Grande-Marlaska’s latest decissions, and about the Justice being independent from the Political power (as it should be in a democracy).

Now, one of them uttered the following phrase:

I don’t think the judges are driven by what the politicians ask them to decide, because if it were so, I’d be very afraid.

Yeah, just like that! Not only once. She repeated the same motto, slightly changed to “[…], because if it were so, we would not be able to say we live in a democracy”

And no one corrected her in any way! No one had the guts to tell her: “Silly you! That is an argumentum ad consequentiam, and therefore a logical fallacy.

What kind of idiots are feeding us with news, if they forget any kind of rigor in their argumentations? Their public display of broken logic will end up idiotizing the spectators, who will assume any non sequitur is a valid argument.


2 Responses to “Journalists + strict logic = ?”

  1. Chell said

    well i’m no journalist, but perhaps the show was directed more to the masses than to journalists with theoretical explanation for everything? ordinary people tend to focus on the content and not the rule behind each argument

  2. isilanes said

    Please note: this blog has moved to handyfloss.net. You can follow this post at http://handyfloss.net/2006.06/journalists-strict-logic/.

    @Chell: I agree, but… do you really understand the implications of what you say? It means that:

    1. The masses are stupid
    2. The journalists know it
    3. They treat us as such
    4. We silently concur

    Logic is not something that you can switch on and off. Everything you say MUST have it, or it is plain bullshit. And the “masses” should learn that.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: